Quick Menu
Search Our Site:

Home >

Print Page

FAQs Common Objections

Question

Answer

  • Is the New Testament Anti-Semitic?

Sometimes you will encounter the assertion that the New Testament is anti-Semitic, and therefore invalid. Of course, this assertion is not true. The authors of the New Testament, who wrote under the inspiration of the Spirit of the God of Israel, were faithful and loyal Jews who loved their own people. These great Jewish men were no more anti-Semitic than the prophet Isaiah, who 700 years earlier wrote in the most scathing terms about our people. Consider the opening words of his book: “Listen O Heavens and hear O Earth; for Adonai speaks: 'Sons I have reared and brought up, but they have revolted against Me. An ox knows its owner, and a donkey its master's manger, but Israel does not know, My people do not understand.' Alas, sinful nation, people weighed down with iniquity, offspring of evildoers, sons who act corruptly!" (Isaiah 1:2-4).

Isaiah told us that the Jewish people, whom the Lord lovingly took care of, and to whom He gave tremendous opportunities, revolted against our Heavenly Father. This made us appear more stupid than the ox or donkey, who at least know who their owners are, and where the feeding trough is. These beasts are grateful to their masters for their loving care, but God's sons were less intelligent than these dumb animals. We no longer knew who our Father was, were far from God, and we refused to return to Him!

Isaiah called the nation of Israel a "goy chotay" - a sinful nation that missed the mark. Of all the nations on Earth, the Creator intended Israel to know Him best of all; to love and obey Him, so that we could bring the knowledge of God, salvation, atonement, the Messiah and eternal life to the other nations of the world, who had strayed so far from the Lord. But the Chosen People were no longer fulfilling His purposes for our nation!

We were weighed down with "avon" - iniquity. Our nation was not straight and upright, but had become bent, crooked, twisted, perverted.

We were described as the offspring of "ray-eem" - evildoers. We consistently failed to do what was good and desirable and beneficial, but were singularly skilled at doing what was harmful and injurious.

We were called "banim mash-chee-teem" - corrupt sons. We had become spoiled. We were marred, destroyed, ruined, like a rotten piece of fruit or a bad piece of meat, which is no longer edible.

We were compared to vile Sodom and corrupt Gomorrah, deserving precisely the same fate as those wicked cities (see 1:9-10). Once we had been like a delightful, beautiful, faithful wife, sharing closeness and intimacy with God, but now were called a "zonah" - a prostitute, a common whore, adulterous and unfaithful to the One we were supposed to be united to. Can you imagine marrying a beautiful young lady, who appears to be virtuous, good, noble, kind, generous and loving, only later to discover that she has been engaging in prostitution? Adonai must have felt hurt, betrayed and angry when His beloved nation became unfaithful to Him, rejecting our covenant with Him, betraying our special relationship to Him (see 1:21). We were once like silver - rare, precious, valuable, beautiful and useful, but we became dross - those worthless metals and impurities that are scraped off in the refining process and are thrown away. Once we were like delicious wine, but we became like cheap wine diluted with water - weak, tasteless and disappointing (see 1:22).

Meanwhile, we were very religious, and assumed that we were completely acceptable to the Almighty! We regularly went to the Temple in Jerusalem and prayed there, making all the various sacrifices that the Torah prescribed, and observing all the holidays and the Sabbath. But in reality we were hypocrites who abandoned the Lord, despised the Holy One of Israel, and turned away from Him (see 1:4, 11-15).

Even though we were engaged in all kinds of religious activities, nevertheless from the Divine perspective we were full of tzo-ah (from "ya-tza" - to go out, to go forth, and so it means that which goes out of the human body - in other words - excrement) that needed to be washed away. From God's perspective, we desperately needed to be washed from our moral and spiritual filthiness (see 4:4).

Therefore, God Himself would become our adversary, and fight against us, raising up terrible enemies who would defeat us. Many Jewish people would be killed. Our magnificent city of Jerusalem would be destroyed and turned into an abandoned field (see 1:24-25, 5:14-17).

Isaiah spelled out the nation's sins in vivid detail, called us insulting names, made graphic and crude references to us, made unflattering and insulting comparisons, and threatened that God Himself would bring upon us the severest punishments, judgments, destruction and death.

Was Isaiah an anti-Semite? Of course not! He was a faithful son of Israel who wanted what was best for his nation. And not surprisingly, interspersed with the insults and judgments, Isaiah also communicated God's continuing love for His sinful nation, His commitment to His people's ultimate well-being, and the glorious future that awaits us.

In their New Testament writings, Paul and Yochanan (John) are usually singled out for alleged anti-Semitism, but the desire of Rabbi Paul's heart was for the salvation of the Jewish people. He was the one who had "great sorrow and unending grief" in his heart for the people whom he loved; so much so, that he would willingly have been separated from God for eternity, if that could have brought about the salvation of Israel. Is that the heart of an anti-Semite? Yochanan was the one who recorded the vision he was shown of eternity, of the glorious New Jerusalem, whose gates are written with the names of the twelve tribes of Israel. Are we to believe this is a Jew-hater? No!

We should learn from both Israel’s prophets and Messiah's emissaries that sometimes love must be blunt, unflattering, even seemingly cruel. There are times when the doctor must inject poisons into the body of his cancer patient for him to live. The surgeon must sometimes employ highly invasive procedures to cut out the cancer if the patient is to survive. The physician must amputate the leg that is full of gangrene for the life of his patient to be sustained. It was the Great Physician who inspired men such as Isaiah, Paul and Yochanan with these very hard words in order to restore us to health and bring about our healing.

I only wish that there were more Isaiahs, Pauls and Yochanans among us, with the love, the courage and the chutzpah to tell us the truth that would turn the United States, and my Jewish people, back to the Holy One of Israel, whom we have likewise abandoned.

Back to Top

Copyright © MMVII Congregation Shema Yisrael. All Rights Reserved Powered by SX Web Solutions