Quick Menu
Search Our Site:

Home >

Print Page

Deuteronomy 21:10-25:19 The Necessity of Law

This week’s parsha Kee Taytsay, meaning, “When you go out” covers Deuteronomy chapters 21 through 25. It has been described by at least one rabbi as “a grab bag” of assorted commands, prohibitions and exhortations. According to Maimonides, this one section of the Torah alone contains 72 separate injunctions. Reducing so many into summary form is a daunting task.

Some liberal theologians argue that many, if not most, of these various commands are irrelevant to today’s world. I couldn’t disagree more! When, for example, we read that we are not to turn a blind eye to our neighbors’ troubles (or that of his animals), or that we are to treat with dignity those who have fallen on hard times and are in our debt, that speaks of compassion. How on earth is that irrelevant? When we are enjoined to return lost property to its rightful owner, and warned that we had better have equal weights and measures, that speaks of honesty in our dealings with one another. How can that be irrelevant? When we are commanded that hired workers be promptly paid a day’s wages for a day’s work, or when we are prohibited from taking advantage of our brother’s financial hardship by charging interest on his loan, that speaks of fairness in our financial dealings. That is hardly irrelevant!

Included also in this section of the Torah are capital offenses, such as kidnapping people and then mistreating or (God forbid!) selling them. Kidnappers were to be put to death. Adultery is also listed as a crime punishable by death. There is a third capital crime listed (though no record of its implementation has ever been recorded): a drunken or gluttonous and rebellious son could be put to death if all parental attempts at correction failed. Scoffers have cited this last example as an argument against the validity of the Scriptures - the idea of putting your own son to death. “What kind of parent would do that?” they argue. But this is not talking about young children - something the scoffer might have learned if he were not simply on a fault-finding mission. After all, how likely is your eight-year old to be a drunkard and a glutton (in other words, a societal degenerate) which is what we read in context?

A lot of things in this parsha sadden me. For example, in chapter 21 men who have more than one wife are warned not to disregard the rights of a first-born son if that son happens to be from one of his wives that he doesn’t love. Accusations by a husband of non-virginity of his wife at the time of their marriage, if proven false, were to be met with a stinging public rebuke and a monetary fine. Laws governing divorce lead off the list in chapter 24. So what we have here is callous favoritism; defamation of character; the dissolution of one’s covenant vow of marriage; Who wouldn’t be saddened? Nor does it seem to get any better. Chapter 22 includes prohibitions against such abominations as cross-dressing (transvestism), adultery and incest. Lovely!

These laws are not, as some suggest, the product of a backward civilization and therefore unnecessary for us today. They are, in fact, a necessary gift - a gift of deterrent - from a loving and all-wise God, who knows perfectly well the depths to which human beings are capable of sinking. These things and much worse fill our newspapers every day, and we even make public spectacles of it on grotesque television shows such as Jerry Springer. You should not be amused, but rather sickened that people watch those shows. Anyone who thinks that our society has advanced morally is deluding himself. Our technology may be developing at warp-speed, but mankind is still wallowing in moral decay, which makes the technology even scarier. We split the atom; we discover the existence of bacteria, we make advancements in chemistry, and from this same technology we manage to cure illnesses and create doomsday weapons.

If there is a theme that may be discerned running through these many and varied commands and prohibitions, it is the need to direct kindness and compassion and justice especially toward those who are the most vulnerable members of society: orphans, widows, unmarried women, those in debt - the very ones most likely to be taken advantage of. In fact it has been argued that because compassion toward the weak and vulnerable is so much a theme here, that chapter 25 ends with a reminder about the Amalekites. When Israel had just come out of Egypt, and were weary and traveling through the wilderness, the Amalekites ambushed us (cf. Ex. 17:8-16, 1 Sam. 15:2-3). In fact we find here in Deuteronomy 25 that they attacked from the rear - precisely where those who were elderly and infirmed (perhaps also women with very young children) were walking, and the Amalekites slaughtered many of us.

This parsha is a confirmation of the wisdom in Yeshua’s answer as to what constitutes the greatest commandment. He said we are to love the Lord our God will all our hearts, and we are to love our neighbor (that means pretty much everybody, in case you were wondering) as ourselves. If we would just pattern our lives according to the 2, the other 611 would not need to have been written. But it is precisely our sinful nature that necessitates the written law, and that written law condemns every one of us, for whoever keeps the whole law, but fails in one point, has become guilty of all (James 2:10 [cf. Deut. 27:26]). Thanks be to God that the requirements of the Law have been fully and finally met through the perfect life, the atoning death and the triumphant resurrection of Messiah Yeshua!

Shalom,
Rabbi Glenn

Copyright © MMVII Congregation Shema Yisrael. All Rights Reserved Powered by SX Web Solutions